Saturday, 9 June 2012

Review: Wildthorn by Jane Eagland

Wildthorn by Jane Eagland
4 out of 5 stars

Published 2009 by Macmillan

I don't know what it is with asylums that attracts me so much. Is it the horror of treatment? The mental illnesses? The big question of how they will get out? Will they be able to escape? Whatever it is, asylums make for great settings in a book. Wildthorn was no exception.

Louisa is a little different than the other girls of her age. She wants to be a doctor. Everyone in her family thinks she is being ridiculous, as doctor is clearly a profession only for men. Louisa should concentrate more on finding a suitable husband, and getting ready to start a family. A few months after the death of her father, she finds herself locked away in an insane asylum. Who sent her here and why? And more importantly, how will she get out?

A common theme in fiction set in the Victorian age is feminism. More often than not the main female character rebels against the set role for women, namely motherhood. What I found interesting in Wildthorn is that even though Louisa rebels against the prejudices, she is no revolutionist. She doesn't want to change the world, call all women to arms, overturn the world's thinking. The only thing she wants is to be left alone, so she can pursue her dream and become a doctor. Her goal is a personal one. She doesn't resent other girls for wanting to marry. She just acknowledges that it's not right way for her. I thought this was very well done, and I admire Ms. Eagland for taking this road, and writing something believable, something that might have actually happened a few hundred years ago.

Louisa is a likeable character. I really felt for her. With flashbacks set at a regular interval throughout the books we learn about her past, everything that has happened to her the past years. I though it was very interesting to read about these events in first person, instead of just being told "hey, five years ago, this happened!". If I would have been in her shoes, I probably would have handled everything the way she did.

A fair warning, this book is not for homophobes. Please don't read this book if you're against lesbian romance. Or if you're against the gay "lifestyle", like most homophobes put it. Don't get me started on homosexuality being a "lifestyle", I can rant about this all day. So I'll just give you a warning. There is a romantic plot, and yes, it's between two girls. Deal with it. It would be such a shame to let your prejudices stand in the way of this great book.

Wildthorn is a very quick read, and a very exciting one. As Louisa slowly unravels the secret of her incarceration, her situation becomes more and more bleak. This book might not be that suitable for the faint of heart. Life in an asylum just isn't roses and sunshine, it's brutal and unfair. Especially towards the end of the book, I couldn't stop reading any more. And when the ending came, I could finally sigh a content sigh. The ending is sweet, cute, and everything it should be.

I definitely recommend this book for anyone that likes historical romance in young-adult form. I think fans of Sarah Waters's Fingersmith might enjoy this too.


Seventeen-year-old Louisa Cosgrove longs to break free from her respectable life as a Victorian doctor's daughter. But her dreams become a nightmare when Louisa is sent to Wildthorn Hall: labeled a lunatic, deprived of her liberty and even her real name. As she unravels the betrayals that led to her incarceration, she realizes there are many kinds of prison. She must be honest with herself - and others - in order to be set free. And love may be the key...

Other reviews you might be interested in
More links


Leah said...

I don't know what it is with asylums that attracts me so much. Is it the
horror of treatment? The mental illnesses? The big question of how they
will get out? Will they be able to escape? Whatever it is, asylums make
for great settings in a book. Wildthorn was no exception.

I haven't heard of this book before, but your opening paragraph was all I needed. The rest of your review only solidified my belief that I'll be all over this book & in the time it took me to post this comment, I found the e-book and it's now on my nook.

Celine said...

That's awesome Leah! Enjoy (:

Mel @thedailyprophecy said...

At first, it's not a book that would catch my interest in the store, but after reading your review, I'm quite interested. That's the thing I love about reviews the most; they can provide you with another book on your to be read list; one you normally wouldn't read :D So thanks for giving me this great review. I'll be checking this one out.

Ashley Prince said...

Wow! I definitely want to read this. I too love books set in asylums. I don't know why. I really, really want to go get this book. 

Celine said...

Haha, I'm the same! Once I find out a book as an asylum, I just HAVE to have it (:

Celine said...

I think that's why this book hasn't done that well during its release - no one is very attracted to it based on the cover or blurb. I had to read a few reviews about it myself before I wanted to buy it. But yeah, reviews make your TBR list grow uncontrollably, haha ^^

Andrea said...

I don't actually know of many books set in asylums (don't think I've actually read any at all), But it definitely would be an interesting topic to pursue. This doesn't seem like one that would naturally peak my interest, but your review has got me a little interested. 

Celine said...

I never thought it would interest me too - but themes like mental illness and the roles of women in society are quite gripping. Don't let big words like that scare you away from Wildthorn though, it's all very subtle in this one (:

Annette said...

I really liked Fingersmith, so now I'm interested in this one. Great review! Thanks.

Celine said...

Thank you Annette! Don't know if you noticed it already, but I added your blog in my "Blogs I Follow" list (:

Celine said...

Aww, thank you so much Aleksandra (: Yeah, I know what you mean, I barely have time to read the books I want to lately. I've been completely neglecting my epic fantasy books because they are so time consuming, but they're awesome too. Hope you'll find some time to read some more historicals soon! ^^

Post a Comment

I love to hear from you!
Make sure to come back as I try to answer all of the comments (: